Wednesday, May 15, 2013

Charles Chesnutt's queer ecology

For the purposes of this talk, I would like to pull from earlier work on a text that lays bare the historical ties between antiblack violence, ecology, and animality: Charles Chesnutt’s The Conjure Woman. Specifically, I am interested in thinking about the various kinds of trans-species transformations that appear in the text, moments where enslaved blacks are transmogrified into various forms of nonhuman life, (e.g. mules, trees, wolves, golems) as a form of punishment for a perceived transgression of the social rules that govern plantation life. Attention to this queer ecology (to use a term invoked most recently by Timothy Morton, though it certainly has a much longer history) where there is no clear delineation between the inside and outside of bodies or hard and fast boundaries that might keep these intra-acting forms of life from slipping into one other, provides an opportunity for us to think in new, helpful ways about the unwieldy entanglements that predominated the lives of enslaved black workers in the material world, the fraught relationships across lines of species that were created during chattel slavery and its afterlife. I also see my talk as an opportunity for us, through the frame of something like queer ecology, to think about what kind of vocabulary Chesnutt's work gives us for living ecologically in the Anthropocene Age, to understand each and every one of ourselves as part of a lived environment that is always already rushing toward us at top speed, transforming us, acting upon humans in ways that unmake any sort of stable, reliable border between the body and nature. For Chesnutt, the primary matter at hand seems to be this very issue of proximity, how life on the plantation, specifically the presence of conjure as a mystical praxis, unmakes this myth of the human as a distant, disinterested master of the nonhuman realm. These slippages across lines of species and matter serve not only to remind us all of our enmeshedness in the natural world, they also emphasize, often to spectacular effect, the dehumanization that African Americans faced in their everyday lives after Emancipation. Many of Chesnutt's characters die or are irreparably injured after their transformation into nonhuman entities, a motif intended to signal a relationship between racial and ecological hegemony that was often ignored in Chesnutt's time, and remains under-theorized (though some contemporary work on environmental racism is certainly broadening the conversation) even now.

1 comment:

  1. Hi Joshua -- This seems to me to be a very productive and exciting way to think about Chesnutt's Conjure Tales. I've taught the Tales as an ecological text that looks forward to both Toomer's Cane and Hurston's Their Eyes, but I've never thought about the queer ecology connection. This might be a great analytic through which to think about Cane as well.

    Some folks have argued that Chesnutt draws heavily on the tradition of American Indian transformation tales (which might also connect to your interests in conjure as mystical praxis above). And in this way, the Tales make some really important claims about race and property -- in my view, the "naturalization" of enslaved people in the Tales reveals the brutal violences committed against enslaved laborers in plantation spaces, but also works to establish an African American land claim to the plantation itself (especially when Sandy becomes a tree on the plantation). But then the traces of American Indian stories in the tales also point to a *prior* land claim to the plantation: that of the indigenous peoples of North Carolina. I think, if I'm remembering correctly, that Jeffrey Myers discusses some (or all) of this in his article, "Other Nature: Resistance to Ecological Hegemony in Charles Chesnutt's The Conjure Woman."

    There's also that brief suggestion that Julius is of mixed race descent, which has always made me wonder if there's a way to think about the various animal-plant-human transgressions and transformations in the Tales as an experimental, and possibly queer, take on the tradition of passing literature, especially since Chesnutt will go on to write several passing novels.

    Looking forward to hearing more about this great project!

    ReplyDelete